Biomimetic sapphire windows enabled by inside-out femtosecond laser deep-scribing

Femtosecond laser machining of biomimetic micro/nanostructures with high aspect ratio (larger than 10) on ultrahard materials, such as sapphire, is a challenging task, because the uncontrollable surface damage usually results in poor surface structures, especially for deep scribing. Here, we report an inside-out femtosecond laser deep scribing technology in combination with etching process for fabricating bio-inspired micro/nanostructures with high-aspect-ratio on sapphire. To effectively avoid the uncontrollable damage at the solid/air interface, a sacrificial layer of silicon oxide was employed for surface protection. High-quality microstructures with an aspect ratio as high as 80:1 have been fabricated on sapphire surface. As a proof-of-concept application, we produced a moth-eye inspired antireflective window with sub-wavelength pyramid arrays on sapphire surface, by which broadband (3–5 μm) and high transmittance (98% at 4 μm, the best results reported so far) have been achieved. The sacrificial layer assisted inside-out femtosecond laser deep scribing technology is effective and universal, holding great promise for producing micro/nanostructured optical devices.

Introduction etching technology has been proven an effective solution to reach this end [12][13][14][15][16][17]. The etching-assisted laser machining technology does not need to undergo intense laser ablation process, it achieves potential microstructures through laser modification. And the removal of materials resorts to subsequent etching process. In this case, inside-out laser machining can be implemented to prepare 3D microstructures, for instance complex microfluidic channel networks. The superiority of this method has been proven in pioneer works with respect to the processing of photosensitive glass, fused silica, et al. For example, Hu et al. have successfully realized complex optofluidic systems inside photosensitive glass by this method [12]. First, 3D modified patterns are designed and fabricated by low-intensity laser scanning from the internal to the surface of the hard materials [18]. Since the laser modified region shows much higher etching rate than the original materials, any desired microstructures can be fabricated by subsequent wet etching or dry etching process. However, in the case of biomimetic fabrication based on ultrahard materials, the etching-assisted laser fabricating usually cannot get precise control of the surface morphology [19]. Since the internal damage threshold is always larger than that at the solid-air interface, uncontrollable surface damage is generally inevitable when the laser scanning path approaches the surface. As a result, plenty of particles, fragments and wrinkles will be generated on the surface, which significantly limits the applications of femtosecond laser in developing delicate biomimetic microstructures. This issue has motivated considerable efforts to develop improved laser micromachining technologies, whereas it remains a big challenge at present.
Here, we proposed an inside-out femtosecond laser deep scribing technology for fabricating biomimetic sapphire window with microstructures on the surface. To effectively avoid the surface and internal damage competition, a silicon oxide (SiO 2 ) with a reasonable thickness is employed as surface sacrificial layer to ensure high-quality and highaspect-ratio structuring. Specifically, the uncontrollable damage to the surface can be well restricted within the sacrificial layer. Since the SiO 2 sacrificial layer and the laser modified sapphire region can be easily removed in the subsequent wet etching process using hydrofluoric acid (HF), biomimetic microstructures with delicate surface morphologies and aspect-ratio as high as 80:1 have been successfully fabricated. Inspired by the infrared light antireflection properties of moth compound eyes, we designed and fabricated the sub-wavelength truncated pyramid array structures on both sides of a sapphire window. In the antireflective tests of infrared rays (IR), it demonstrated broadband (3-5 μm) and high transmittance (98% at 4 μm) for normal incidence.

Experimental section
To modify the samples, we used a femtosecond laser with wavelength of 343 nm, which is delivered by third harmonic generation system (Pharos, Light Conversion Ltd). The repetition rate of femtosecond laser is 200 kHz and the pulse width is 290 fs. The samples were fixed on a high-precision three-dimensional nanoscale positioning platform (PI, E-727.3CDA). Then, the laser beam was focused in the samples by an objective lens (Nikon 20×) with numerical aperture of 0.75. In this way, by moving the platform that can be controlled by computer aided design (CAD), three-dimensional micro/nanostructures can be realized via femtosecond laser modification. Then, wet etching was carried out by using 10% HF aqueous solution to remove the sacrificial layer of SiO 2 and the laser modified regions in sapphire (Hefei Kejing Material Technology, Ltd., thickness of 430 μm). The etching time depends on the depth of the structures. Dry etching process for fabrication of antireflective microstructures was carried out by an inductively coupled plasma system (ICP-100A, Tailong Electronics, Ltd). The etching power was controlled to 600 W of antenna RF power and 300 W of bias RF power. The etching time was 5 min. Chlorine (Cl 2 ) and boron trichloride (BCl 3 ) were chosen as the etching gas with flow rates of 20 and 30 sccm. Field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM, JEOL JSM-6700F, Japan) was used to show the surface morphology and crosssection of the fabricated microstructures. The three-dimensional morphologies of the antireflective microstructures were measured by laser scanning confocal microscopy (LSCM, OLS4100, Japan). The transmittance of sapphire with antireflective microstructures was investigated using Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometry.

Results and discussion
Generally, the femtosecond laser pulse exhibits a Gaussian distribution of intensity. To fabricate deep microstructures with high aspect ratio on sapphire, focused laser spot has to scan from inside to outside gradually. Such an inside-out processing can avoid the scattering effect caused by the surface damage, and thus guarantee high resolution and surface smoothness. Nevertheless, when the laser fluence at the focus center reaches the internal damage threshold of sapphire, the laser fluence beyond the central region may exceed the surface damage threshold, since the damage threshold at the solid/air interface is always much lower than that inside the bulky material. As a result, the sapphire surface is more vulnerable to damage when scanning the laser focus from inside to out, especially approaching the surface. To demonstrate this effect clearly, we stimulate the intensity distribution of a laser focus underneath the solid surface, as shown in Fig. 1. Due to the difference in surface and internal damage threshold, uncontrollable damage is always inevitable at the solid-air interface. Consequently, an undamaged. region with a certain depth (denoted as dz) usually forms underneath the surface damages (Fig. 1a). The uncontrollable surface damages lead to poor surface morphology, and the undamaged region underneath the surface may also prevent the subsequent etching process. The combined effects make it challenging to prepare delicate biomimetic microstructures. To get deep insight into the depth of undamaged region, we stimulate the dependance of dz on the laser fluence. Generally, the Gaussian light intensity of a femtosecond laser can be described by the following formula: with where A 0 /ω z is the amplitude of the electric vector at different position of z axis, r is the perpendicular distance to z axis, λ is the wavelength, and ω 0 is the waist radius at (2) ω z = ω 0 1 + z πω 0 2 2 z = 0. Then, the distance (d z ) between surface damage threshold I 1 and internal damage threshold I 2 can be described by the following formula: The relationship of d z and A 2 0 is shown in Fig. 1b, in which dz increases with the laser fluence, following a quasi-linear relationship. SEM image (inset of Fig. 1b) confirms the presence of such an undamaged region even after HF etching.
To address this issue, we proposed a sacrificial layer-assisted laser micromachining strategy. Figure 1c shows the comparison of the laser processing and subsequent etching process with and without the sacrificial layer. Generally, the femtosecond laser irradiation can induce the phase change of sapphire from crystalline phase to amorphous/ polycrystalline phase, and the laser modified region can be rapidly etched away by HF solution with the etching selectivity over 104 [7]. In a typical laser processing experiment, the laser fluence can be tuned slightly larger than the phase change threshold of sapphire. The presence of sacrificial layer (here we use SiO 2 ) with a suitable thickness generate a new air/SiO 2 two-phase interface instead of the air/sapphire interface, which effectively avoids the surface damage at the sapphire. Thus, the undamaged region appears in the SiO 2 sacrificial layer, which can be removed during HF etching. In this way, the desired microstructures with high aspect ratio and good surface quality can be readily prepared (Fig. 1c).
To clarify the fundamental of the formation of undamaged regions in sapphire, we fabricated a series of single-line grooves by varying the depth of the laser focus, and systematically investigated the dependence of the depth and width of the grooves on the relative position of the laser focus to the sapphire surface. Figure 2a shows the scheme of the laser focus depth and the profile SEM image of the resultant micro-grooves fabricated. Notably, when the laser is focused outside the sapphire, surface damage can be induced providing the laser intensity at the solid-air interface reach the damage threshold of sapphire. In this condition, the as-formed grooves are relatively shallow. When the laser focus is tuned downward gradually, both the depth and the width of the grooves are increased. Nevertheless, when the laser is focused underneath the sapphire surface, further increase of the laser focus depth would not increase the size of the grooves, since the as-formed surface damages prevent the deep scribing of sapphire. In this condition, the laser fluence of the focus edge reached the damage threshold of sapphire at the solidair interface, and the center of laser focus reach the damage threshold of bulky sapphire, while the intensity under the surface damage and far from the focus center is below the damage threshold. As a result, an undamaged region appears underneath the grooves. When the laser focus was assigned deep inside the sapphire, only inside damage was formed, and the surface keeps smooth. The profile SEM image of these grooves (after HF etching) confirms evolution of the profile structures. Figure 2b shows the dependence of the profile morphologies of the grooves on relative depth of laser focus. The depth and width of the grooves first increased with laser focus depth following the same tendency. When they reach a maximum value, the depth and width decreased due to the formation of undamaged region underneath the grooves. In this case, deep scribing of sapphire will be suppressed in the presence of undamaged region.
To realize deep scribing of sapphire, we have to avoid the formation of uncontrollable surface damages and the undamaged region underneath. In this work, we proposed a sacrificial layer-assisted laser micromachining strategy. A SiO 2 film with a suitable thickness was employed as a sacrificial layer on the surface of sapphire. By this way, the undamaged region would appear in the sacrificial layer, and can be removed during the etching process, forming deep and connected microstructures with high aspect ratio. To make sure that the undamaged region appears in the sacrificial layer, the thickness of SiO 2 film should be larger than the depth of undamaged region. In this regard, we investigated the dependence of the depth of undamaged region and the laser fluence. Experimentally, the thickness of undamaged region increased from approximately 0.7 to 1.6 μm with laser fluence increasing from 105 to 180 J/cm 2 (Fig. 2c). Therefore, the thickness of SiO 2 film that deposited on the surface of sapphire should be larger than 2 μm. In theory, we also investigated their relationship. The simulated light intensity distribution (the insets of Fig. 2c) shows the amplified intensity distribution length, which is agree with the experimental results. Figure 2d shows the comparable scheme and the profile SEM image of the microgrooves. In the presence of a sacrificial layer, the sapphire-air interface changes to SiO 2 -air interface. As a result, sapphire grooves with high aspect ratios can be readily fabricated. Introducing a cover glass with a thickness of 150 μm has been used in inscribing waveguide near the surface. However, this method requires a higher flatness to the substrate to form Vander Waals attractive forces between the atoms of the surfaces [20,21]. In our work, the sacrificial layer of SiO 2 was fabricated by electron beam evaporation. The deposited SiO 2 film can eliminate the residual air in the interface which is easy to form when the substrate is not a strict flat surface.
By introducing SiO 2 as a sacrificial layer, the undamaged region would appear in the SiO 2 layer, which could be removed by HF etching. Thus, various micro/nanostructures of high aspect ratio could be fabricated on sapphire surface through an inside-out deep scribing manner. Figure 3 shows the SEM images of several typical microstructures fabricated on sapphire surface. Both the surface patterns and the section profiles of these microstructures can be designed and fabricated by programming the laser scanning path. For example, a wave lines array with a line width of 800 nm has been fabricated on ultra-hard sapphire surface using this method (Fig. 3a). Magnified SEM image shows that the surface of the wave-line structure is quite smooth, no crack and damage can be detected around it (Fig. 3b), indicating the high precision. Besides, a split ring array with an average resolution of 1 μm and a period of 8 μm has been fabricated on sapphire (Fig. 3c). Actually, taking advantage of the designable processing capability, any desired patterns can be readily produced on sapphire. Figure 3d and e demonstrate a continuous square coil structure and an interdigital structure, respectively. Through an inside-out writing manner, the depth of microstructures can be flexibly tuned by controlling the laser scanning depth. Figure 3f shows the profile of the microstructures of different depth, in which the aspect ratio as high as 80:1 has been achieved. In fact, this value can be further increased with increasing the laser scanning depth. The results indicated that this method enables fabricating high-quality microstructures with high aspect ratio on sapphire, holding great promise for biomimetic fabrication.
Inspired by the cornea of moth eye that has excellent antireflection properties, we demonstrated the fabrication of sub-wavelength antireflection structures on sapphire for optical window applications. Sapphire can act as the optical window materials in the mid-IR region owing to its high thermal, mechanical and chemical stability, and high transmittance in the IR spectral region [22,23]. In addition to the intrinsic high transmission of the window materials, antireflection sub-wavelength structures can offer a gradient refractive index profile between two sides of the interface, which can significantly enhance the transmission [24][25][26][27][28][29]. To date, to realize structure induced transmission enhancement, various advanced technologies, for instance, electron-beam etching, laser interference, and mask lithography have been employed to fabricate subwavelength antireflection structures [30][31][32][33][34][35]. However, these methods are not suitable for such biomimetic fabrication on sapphire, because the high mechanical strength and chemical stability make it challenging to fabricate of sub-wavelength microstructures. Various femtosecond laser-based methods have been proposed to fabricate sapphire microstructures [36][37][38]. However, these methods cannot meet the requirements of infrared window structure for high resolution and high surface quality. In this work, we successfully fabricated antireflection sub-wavelength structures on sapphire using the sacrificial layer assisted inside-out deep laser scribing technology. Figure 4a-c shows the morphology of the cornea of moth eye. On the surface of the compound eyes, there are hundreds of ommatidia closely packed on a curved surface. On each ommatidium, micropillar arrays distributed periodically on the surface. The ommatidia function as cameras, and the micropillar arrays are helpful for transmission enhancement. Inspired from this interesting structure, we designed antireflection subwavelength structures, pyramidal structure array with an average period of 2 μm. The parameters of the antireflection sub-wavelength structure were determined by the following formula according to the effective medium theories (EMT's) [39] (the schematic of the designed structures can be seen in Supplement 1, Fig. S1): where p is the period of antireflection sub-wavelength structures, n 2 =1.77 is the refractive index of sapphire, n 1 =1 is the refractive index of air, θ max =90° is the maximum value of incident angle. Accordingly, the period of antireflection sub-wavelength (4) p = 1 n 2 + n 1 sinθ max structures should be less than 2.26 μm for a typical IR wavelength (λ) of 4 μm (popular in IR cameras).
The planar periodicity of the sub-wavelength antireflection structure determines the operating wavelength, while the height and shape of the pattern determine the antireflection performance. The optimal height of the structure (h) for a minimal reflectivity is: [39] where λ is the typical IR wavelength of 4 μm, and n 1 and n 2 are the refractive indices of sapphire and air, respectively. Thus, the height of the antireflection sub-wavelength structures should be larger than 0.75 μm. The size and height of micro/nanostructures is critical to the optical performance [40,41]. To satisfy the requirement of the period and the height, we employed a sacrificial layer for the inside-out laser deep scribing of sapphire. Since both the sacrificial layer and the laser modified region can be removed with the help of HF etching, the antireflection sub-wavelength structures have been successfully fabricated through our method (Fig. 4d). SEM images of the moth eye inspired antireflection sapphire window show the uniform distribution of a close-pack subwavelength structures over a large area (Fig. 4e-h). Magnified SEM image (Fig. 4g) confirms the good surface smoothness. Cross-section profile indicates that the height of the antireflection structure is approximately 1 μm (Fig. 4i). It is worthy pointing out that it is quite challenging to fabricate such a biomimetic antireflection structure on sapphire surface through a general femtosecond laser modification and etching method, the presence of a sacrificial layer plays the key role to achieve high-quality antireflection structures. As a control experiment, we also fabricated the same structure on sapphire under the same condition without the use of the sacrificial layer, the rough surface confirm the importance of the sacrificial layer (Fig. S2). The optical performance of the antireflection structures was investigated using Fourier transform infrared spectrometry. As compared with the pristine sapphire, the transmittance of the sapphire with antireflection structures increased significantly in the mid-infrared range from 2.5 to 6 μm (Fig. 5a). The sapphire glass with antireflection structures on both sides shows a transmittance of ~ 98% at 4 μm, and the one with antireflection structures on one side shows a transmittance of ~ 92%. Both of them are much higher than that of the plane one (86%). The theoretical simulations by Virtu-alLab Fusion software shows the similar value of the transmittance in the three cases (Fig. 5b), in good agreement with our experimental results. Additionally, the transmission dependence on the incidence angle was also investigated both experimentally and theoretically (Fig. 5c-f ). With increasing of the incidence angle from 0 to 50°, the transmission of sapphire with antireflection structures on both sides decreased slightly, but still above 95% at 4 μm. Further increase of incidence angle to 70° would cause the obvious decrease of transmission to 89% at μm (Fig. 5c, d). The theoretical calculations for the sapphire sample with two side antireflection structures shows an angle-independent transmission and reflection up to 70° for the non-polarized light at 4 μm (Fig. 5f ), which shows a similar tendency with the experimental results.
Conclusion In summary, we proposed an inside-out femtosecond laser deep scribing technology for fabricating biomimetic microstructures with high-aspect-ratio on sapphire. By introducing a sacrificial layer of SiO 2 on sapphire surface, uncontrollable surface damages and the undamaged region underneath can be effectively avoided. As a result, high-quality microstructures with a maximum aspect ratio of 80:1 have been readily produced on sapphire surface. In addition, to demonstrate the full potential of this technology in biomimetic microfabrication, a uniform pyramidal structures array inspired from the cornea of moth eye have been fabricated on sapphire. A broadband angle independent transmittance for incidence angles up to 70° and a high transmittance of ~ 98% at 4 μm have been achieved. The biomimetic sapphire processing technology may hold great promise for producing micro-optical devices that can work under harsh conditions.